<$BlogRSDUrl$>

Tuesday, September 27, 2005

Mary Mapes has a book coming out 
It's called "Truth and Duty: the Press, the President, and the Priveledge of Power."
The first chapter is online. Here are some exerpts. With, of course, my own insufferable commentary interspersed throughout, as is my wont.

We had a senior document analyst named Marcel Matley fly to New York to look at all the documents we had, the official documents that had been previously released by the White House as well as the “new” ones. After examining them for hours, blowing up signatures and comparing curves, strokes, and dots, he gave his best opinion on their authenticity. Since the documents were copies, not originals, he could not offer the 100 percent assurance that came by testing the ink or the paper.

But he said he saw nothing in the typeface or format to indicate the memos had been doctored or not produced at the time they were alleged to have been.


Hilarious.

It was another day of exhausted exultation. I got congratulatory e-mails, phone calls, and pats on the back. Other reporters called repeatedly as they worked to catch up to my story. I was thrilled.

All that changed about 11:00 a.m., when I first started hearing rumbles from some producers at CBS News that a handful of far right Web sites were saying that the documents had been forged.

I was incredulous. That couldn’t be possible. Even on the morning the story aired, when we showed the president’s people the memos, the White House hadn’t attempted to deny the truth of the documents. In fact, the president’s spokesman, Dan Bartlett, had claimed that the documents supported their version of events: that then-lieutenant Bush had asked for permission to leave the unit.

Within a few minutes, I was online visiting Web sites I had never heard of before: Free Republic, Little Green Footballs, Power Line. They were hard-core, politically angry, hyperconservative sites loaded with vitriol about Dan Rather and CBS.


The Freepers and LGF, ok. But Powerline? Politically angry? Please.

All these Web sites had extensive write-ups on the documents: on typeface, font style, and peripheral spacing, material that seemed to spring up overnight. It was phenomenal. It had taken our analysts hours of careful work to make comparisons. It seemed that these analysts or commentators---or whatever they were---were coming up with long treatises in minutes. They were all linking to one another, creating an echo chamber of outraged agreement.


Well, the fact is that the media "analysts" are overpaid and not very good. And when it comes to anything having ANYTHING remotely to do with the military, the Manhattan media has a significant demographic handicap to overcome: There are so few veterans in the Manhattan media circles that Manhattan media does not even have the perspective to realize how bad their analysis is. Anyone who has spent time reading official military correspondence could see instantly that the memos did not come from a military headquarters.

There was no analysis of what the documents actually said, no work done to look at the content, no comparison with the official record, no phone calls made to check the facts of the story, nothing beyond a cursory and politically motivated examination of the typeface. That was all they had to attack, but that was enough.


You come up with a pig and you tell me it's a dog. You even produce a dog's pedigree. But people who spend a lifetime farming pigs know a pig when they see it. And you swearing up and down that it's a pig don't make the pig look any more like a dog. But it does make you look like an idiot.

I remember staring, disheartened and angry, at one posting. “60 Minutes is going down,” the writer crowed exultantly.

My heart started to pound. There is nothing more frightening for a reporter than the possibility of being wrong, seriously wrong. That is the reason that we checked and rechecked, argued about wording, took care to be certain that the video that accompanied the words didn’t create a new and unintended nuance. Being right, being sure, was everything. And right now, on the Internet, it appeared everything was falling apart.

I had a real physical reaction as I read the angry online accounts. It was something between a panic attack, a heart attack, and a nervous breakdown. My palms were sweaty; I gulped and tried to breathe. My heart was pounding like I had become a cartoon character whose heart outline pushes out the front of her shirt with each beat. The little girl in me wanted to crouch and hide behind the door and cry my eyes out.


Remember that feeling. Maybe you'll be more careful about playing "gotcha journalism." Maybe you'll be more careful before you fuck up another story.

talked to our document analyst Marcel Matley, now back in San Francisco, who said he had seen some of the comments and dismissed them out of hand. “They aren’t even looking at the quality of copies I did,” Matley said. He disdained the anonymity of the postings, saying that any real analysts would use their name and credentials. And he pointed out something that would be a huge problem for us in the days ahead: that in the process of downloading, scanning, faxing, and photocopying, some computers, copiers, and faxes changed spacing and subtly altered fonts. He thought that this basic misunderstanding of how documents changed through electronic transmittal was behind the unfounded certainty and ferocity of the attack on the documents.

In retrospect, Matley was right and our story never recovered from this basic misunderstanding. Faxing changes a document in so many ways, large and small, that analyzing a memo that had been faxed---in some cases not once, but twice---was virtually impossible. The faxing destroyed the subtle arcs and lines in the letters. The characters bled into each other. The details of how the typed characters failed to line up perfectly inside each word were lost.

And these faxed, scanned, and downloaded documents were the only versions of the memos ever made public. A comparison of one of the documents before faxing and after faxing is in the appendix.


Heh. That didn't stop this idiot from certifying these memos as authentic. Sure, a fax distorts certain things. But it's not going to automatically put a courier typefont into the exact default settings of Microsoft Word, AND retain the integrity of someone's signature at the bottom of the page. If a fax was so distorting, then what on earth was this guy analyzing in the first place? This "analyst" is covering his tracks like a cat buries a turd.

Next time, why don't you ask the fox about the henhouse?

I was afraid that this time Matley, who was an experienced document analyst and longtime expert witness, was out of his element. He knew a great deal about documents and signatures. But I knew attack politics.


No, Mary. You THOUGHT you knew attack politics. Which is why you were so willing to believe that these memos were authentic.

Actually, 60 Minutes has a long history of slandering the innocent to make a compelling TV story. Mapes's victim complex is wearing a bit thin - especially when one stops to consider the many reputations that overzealous news producers like her have so wantonly destroyed. Richard Jewell, anybody?

I knew I could count on Dan. In tough situations, he became “fightin’ Dan,” someone who told us all to “never back up, never back down, never give up, never give in.” I was glad to hear from him and reassured by his reaction to all of it.


Not a word about a journalist's first allegiance being to the truth. I guess those days are over, if they ever existed. If these people are more interested in the fight than the truth, then they should all be fired so they can find PR jobs somewhere in the spin factories.

I was incredulous that the mainstream press---a group I’d been a part of for nearly twenty-five years and thought I knew---was falling for the blogs’ critiques. I was shocked at the ferocity of the attack. I was terrified at CBS’s lack of preparedness in defending us. I was furious at the unrelenting attacks on Dan. And I was helpless to do anything about any of it.

We vowed to work ourselves into a frenzy doing a great report on the Evening News the next night ... and we did. We put on a strong and reasoned defense. Maybe that was the problem. The people who had begun the attack on us were not interested in reason, other than the reason behind the whole assault---politics.


If Mapes were interested in reason, she and her team would have quickly produced a convincing explanation as to how it was possible for a 1973 typewriter to produce a memo using the exact same default settings as Microsoft Word 32 years later. They would have come up with a typewriter who could do it. They would have explained why their source burned the originals (Maybe to get rid of the printer ink?).

Mary Mapes has failed to stick up for her own story here. All she has is ad hominems against the bloggers, and unproven speculation about their motives. Well, if someone can demonstrate that the memos were fake happens to have a political motive, that does nothing to undercut the fact that the memos were fake. Indeed, Mapes' speculation about the motives of the bloggers is in and of itself bad journalism practice. What is the evidence that political motivations colored the obvious conclusions anyone with an experienced eye for military correspondence could have reached by looking at the document?

Yes, Mapes is still acting like a wounded wildebeest. She's demonstrated no insight so far, and demonstrated no allegiance whatsoever to the truth.

I'd have a lot more respect for her if she simply argued that the memos were fake (but I still believe the story because of A, B, and C.)

She's fighting her battle on the wrong turf here.

And her narcissism reminds me of Blair's.


Splash, out

Jason

Comments:
Something stinks. This wasn't the story they were using back then. Back then it was 'faxed'. That's it. No talk of 'downloading' or 'scanning'. Now I don't know that any part of 'downloading' would substantially change a document from it's original format before the download - a scanned doc in .tiff or .pdf retains it's qualities thru a 'download' - that's kind of the point of file formats, innit? But then, downloading as a term is used by so many people in so many ways it almost has no meaning anymore, so we'd have to go back to the source to find out what he meant by it. And you/Jason touched on this, but it bears revisting - according to her book account, their 'expert' didn't bring all of this up on his first view - he only brought it up after the initial challenges from the blogosphere had come out.

But scanning, IF - the docs were scanned, and IF - the docs were run thru an OCR process that output the characters in another format/font, OK yes, then you have output in MS word fonts, if setup that way. But then, you've substantially CHANGED the document, and it's no longer authentic. (and if so, why wasn't this disclosed originally???) If a fax machine or system does that, I'd like to hear about it. How about an account of the timeline on what all the documents went thru, from start to finish? Name dates, and most importantly EQUIPMENT and software used, all the way thru to their airing on TV - a chain of evidence. No, that would be factual news reporting, and possibly expose flaws along the way. And, it all comes back to the 'original source' problem - it doesn't exist anymore.

At best, Mary Mapes is unforgivably clueless about the tools of her trade. If she didn't know about the workings behind faxes, downloading, scanning, OCR, typefaces, fonts, etc, she had no business bringing this out as a story. (Note to news editors: veterans tend to be '_technically_ and tactically proficient' in their jobs. Had MM been a veteran, this might not have happened!)
 
Here's a laugher:

It was another day of exhausted exultation. I got congratulatory e-mails, phone calls, and pats on the back. Other reporters called repeatedly as they worked to catch up to my story. I was thrilled.

Followed by this:

They were all linking to one another, creating an echo chamber of outraged agreement.


How is this, even if true, any different from reporters calling her to 'catch up' to get the story from CBS reproduced (as opposed to originally reported) in their own outlets? OH the hypocracy.
 
That's not even the best quote by the slightest - (from the Amazon excerpt)

I often wondered what those women thought I did for a living. Disheveled and limping, straggling along with a heavy briefcase full of files, I entered the hotel lobby each night looking like a failing hooker for that small subset of customers who preferred exhausted, unkempt professional women.

'Ooh-la-la! Now we're talkin'! Hey baby, let's file the long form, if you know what I mean...that is, unless you're too exhausted from your long day of professional work...'

Having made my cheap shot, I'm calling on the right wing blogosphere to show restraint and sacrifice this one to the innuendo gods. Mary Mapes putting herself in a hooker simile - it's just too easy!!!
 
I discuss this topic daily myself. I also have a website that talks about juice make money xango related things. Go check it out if you get a chance.
 
Homeworkers Needed Immediately! Over 300 work at home firms that want to pay you! Take surveys online and get paid $150/hour, assemble crafts, mail circulars, mystery shopper positions available and more! For this complete report of over 300 firms please PayPal $25.00 to (telecoms24-workathome@yahoo.com) and we will send you the information to your e-mail address. If you want any additional information before ordering please e-mail me at (telecoms24-workathome@yahoo.com)
 
Nice site i came here searching for anyone can make money online and was looking for other people who are interested in anyone can make money online
You might be interested in anyone can make money online
 
I liked your blog covering home business resource. Anyone entering the field of running a home business needs to do their research first and our web site also covers home business resource and related topics. Check it out if you can as we have many articles on running a home business.
 
Increase your Search Engine Rank in Days noy Months!
 
adult personals canada
adult personals canada
 
So your interested in free asian porn

There is a new Adult Press Release site out there to release adult porn related news!

Its called Porn Biz

Check it out free asian porn
 
Howdy. Ok, that is a little rural, but but my thinking is big time! I love talking and reading about
successful home business I am sure you do to from the looks of your blog. Live long and prosper!
 
can i get more information?
 
thanks for the info
 
Hello. Out surfing around to see how other people market mlm opportunity lead
and there products. I hope your blog works well for you. http://veretekk.blastomatic.com/marjac
 
I appreciate your blogs content. Gotta run.
cheap computers
 
Hi there, I have came by in search of information. I was told that blogs have some of the best and most relevent information for any given subject. Mine happens to be a adams horse and pet supply gift website that has anything from jewelry to horse tack. So I am looking for new products and information based on adams horse and pet supply to offer my customers and possibly some good marketing ideas for my website.

Websites that I have and all the work involved in keeping several of them going and updating blogs I am at best posting once a month.

I have enjoyed your blog and am thankfull to be able to sort of pick your brain without actually bothering you.

I want to grow and build my website to be the best and know I have much to learn and fix to even come close.

I have been online for 8 months now so yes we are very young.

We have taken what we love and have turned it into a business.
I hope you come by to visit. I am not trying to sale you anything but would love to here if you have any ideas.

Thank you for your time.
adams horse and pet supply
 
I enjoyed reading your blog. I�ve been browsing the net for something related to yahoo personals and found this site - http://top-personals.net. It�s a guide to online personals and yahoo personals.
 
Hello ##NAME##, with all the information on legit work at home jobs I became very overwhelmed. Anyway, I was online doing a specific search for the most current information on legit work at home jobs and somehow I ended up on your site. ##NAME## to be frank, ##TITLE## wasn't not the exact match to what I was looking for, but boy am I glad I'm here. You've certainly managed to grab me attention and peak my interest. I must say this is a great blog and I'm most certainly happy that I stopped by eventhough it wasn't the legit work at home jobs related information I was looking for. Thanks. Keep up the good work.
 
Hello ##NAME##, with all the information on work from home jobs I became very overwhelmed. Anyway, I was online doing a specific search for the most current information on work from home jobs and somehow I ended up on your site. ##NAME## to be frank, ##TITLE## wasn't not the exact match to what I was looking for, but boy am I glad I'm here. You've certainly managed to grab me attention and peak my interest. I must say this is a great blog and I'm most certainly happy that I stopped by eventhough it wasn't the work from home jobs related information I was looking for. Thanks. Keep up the good work.
 
Hello, I have a fairly new website that has been online for about 8 months. I looked at alot of websites that are in my area show horse equipment . I have done the internet MLM thing and really got disgusted at the whole thing. So my wife and I thought since we love horses we should build a website around that. We have done pretty good so far but I always want to improve. I didn;t realize it would be so time consuming though. But we love it and hope to improve and offer some of the best recourses and products available. Hence the search for content new products and information about what we have. If you decide to come and visit maybe you can offer some advice That would be great. If not well you have A great new year.

Thank you for your BLOG.

Regards,

show horse equipment
 
Hi there, I have came by in search of information. I was told that blogs have some of the best and most relevent information for any given subject. Mine happens to be a horse equipment auction gift website that has anything from jewelry to horse tack. So I am looking for new products and information based on horse equipment auction to offer my customers and possibly some good marketing ideas for my website.

Websites that I have and all the work involved in keeping several of them going and updating blogs I am at best posting once a month.

I have enjoyed your blog and am thankfull to be able to sort of pick your brain without actually bothering you. Blogs tend to stand out because a lot of them people don't try and sale so much as to write about things that they enjoy or what they like to do.
Most of which comes out in there writing.

I want to grow and build my website to be the best and know I have much to learn and fix to even come close.

I have been online for 8 months now so yes we are very young.

We have taken what we love and have turned it into a business.
I hope you come by to visit. I am not trying to sale you anything but would love to here if you have any ideas.

Thank you for your time.
horse equipment auction
 
Hello Blogger, I’m just searching the web for the next big thing on 888 biz and noticed your great site. Although this post wasn’t actually what I was looking for it DID get my attention and interest. I see now why I found your great
website when I was searching for 888 biz related information and I’m thankful I found your blogsite even though its not an exact match. Excellent Post, thanks for the read (It’s a keeper).
 
Good info. Thanks.

Regards,

Emini Russell 2000 Futures Daytrader
intuitive day trading
 
Hello ##NAME##, with all the information on legitimate work from home jobs I became very overwhelmed. Anyway, I was online doing a specific search for the most current information on legitimate work from home jobs and somehow I ended up on your site. ##NAME## to be frank, ##TITLE## wasn't not the exact match to what I was looking for, but boy am I glad I'm here. You've certainly managed to grab me attention and peak my interest. I must say this is a great blog and I'm most certainly happy that I stopped by eventhough it wasn't the legitimate work from home jobs related information I was looking for. Thanks. Keep up the good work.
 
I have been following a site now for almost 2 years and I have found it to be both reliable and profitable. They post daily and their stock trades have been beating
the indexes easily.

Take a look at Wallstreetwinnersonline.com

RickJ
 
Hi, Just browsing around for ideas for my site. (While we're at the same topic), I'm just getting started if you want to visit:
web site hosting cheap

Charles
 
Thanks for all the great comments and insights..By the way, are you looking for more information on baby phat diamond jewelry ..If so here is a fantastic resource for everything related to baby phat diamond jewelry with information, products, articles and more..Check it out here...http://www.aphroditesaccessories.com
 
Hi blogger:)

Well done - We can hardly receive a comment on my web blog.. The only comments We have are ones that my brother created:) Hope U keep Urs great as much as it is now!! Cheers:)

Regards,
extra make money
 
Hi blogger:)

We shall inform all my school friends about this web blog...... they were searching for the same info a couple of days/weeks ago.. If they still need that info they will adore Ur web blog:)

Regards,
make money fast
 

business economy Business Plan - Unique Approaches That Accelerate Your Business Plan
Chronicle Of One Man's Meteoric Rise To Internet Fame and Fortune ... and How You Can Do The Same For Your Business!

If you wanted to learn how to become successful in the online information industry, who would you rather hear from? A "copycat" or the guy who pioneered the system? It's a "no-brainer," isn't it?

Discover the humble beginnings of this info product genius and learn how he overcame the same struggles you are faced with every single day in your online business. In fact, once you read Leap Ahead, you'll marvel at how simple it can be for you!
Take your own "leap of faith". Business Plan business economy

 
Hello, we have just finished creating this free questions and answers forum for members of The Country Club Biz. Please check it out at CC Biz Forum
 
Post a Comment

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?

Site Meter

Prev | List | Random | Next
Powered by RingSurf!

Prev | List | Random | Next
Powered by RingSurf!