Saturday, May 29, 2004
Damn lies, Guardian Lies, and Statistics (Off Topic)
The Guardian's Polly Toynbee has a theory that 1.) The US is the most unequal society in the world, while the Scandinavians had the most equal; 2.) That the US is the most obese society in the world, while the Scandinavians are the least obese society in the world, and that 3.) It follows that inequality must cause obesity. Simply increase the levels of equality in the US, and we'll lose weight like magic.
Point number 3 is logically fallacious on its face. Correlation does not demonstrate causality.
But she's even dead wrong about the correlations, as the Daily Ablution convincingly points out.
Splash, out
Jason
Point number 3 is logically fallacious on its face. Correlation does not demonstrate causality.
But she's even dead wrong about the correlations, as the Daily Ablution convincingly points out.
Splash, out
Jason
Comments:
weight loss diet Weight Loss Tips - 101 Weight Loss Plan
101 Plan to Lose 10 Pounds or more and Keep it Off!
There was a time in this world when the need to lose weight was completely unheard of. People ate well, but the worked well too. They woke up early in the morning and then engaged in a whole day's work.
The world has changed so much since those days. Life styles have changed and the comforts and facilities have increased so much. But every rose has its thorn. Weight Loss Tips weight loss diet
Post a Comment
Everyone has a method of reducing the obesity rate. Especially those who are not fat. Whoopee.
Well, almost everyone: after the silly BMI (Marilyn Monroe was seriously underweight? Michael Jordan was teetering between obesity and morbid obesity?) was adopted it was decided it was not scary enough, so it was "adjusted" and roughly 20 million US citizens went from "normal" to "obese" without gaining an ounce...
Now, I consider myself fat-to-obese. And I keep reading medical weblogs, occasionally seeing posts about it. And my own "primary physician" is actually a medical clinic at a teaching hospital, so when the interns/residents turn over each year I get the start of the weight lecture.
Why just "the start" of the lecture? Because I interrupt and tell them -
^ A few years ago I was hospitalized for two weeks. During
^ that time I ate the same hospital food as everyone else,
^ and of course the same portions. I got the same amount of
^ exercise - a bit more than I normally do.
^
^ I gained twelve pounds in those two weeks.
^
^ If you aren't prepared to offer a believable reason for
^ that, I cannot accept anything you say except that cutting
^ down to 1200 calories per day and walking five miles per
^ day would cause a weight loss. It would also kill me, but
^ does that bother you?
I've never had anyone attempt the lecture a second time.
Changing diet and exercise will help most (well, those who can stand it) people. Note, though, it has to be a permanent change: lose-gain-lose-gain cycling is FAR more unhealthy than being overweight, up to the "morbidly" obese point.
Once you have a certain percentage of fat, it is like a cancer, if somewhat easier to treat. Indeed, one study found that some cancer-indicators in the blood also applied to fat buildup, and some cancer treatments (the ones that attack the cancer by recognizing the blood change and cutting off flow to capillaries with large concentrations of the changed blood chemistry) were effective in controlling weight: not conclusive as yet, a lot of research needs to be done, but if borne out offers hope. -
http://www.reuters.com/newsArticle.jhtml;jsessionid=KIBCCNTVLXBUMCRBAE0CFEY?type=scienceNews&storyID=5082664
Study: Molecule 'Vacuums Up' Fat from Mice
A new approach being used to fight cancer may also help fight fat, U.S. researchers said on Sunday. ... When fat mice were injected with the new "fat-zapper" every day for a month, they all slimmed down to normal weight with no visible side-effects, the researchers reported in the June [2004] issue of Nature Medicine. ... In cancer, a new class of drugs called angiogenesis inhibitors starve tumors by cutting off their blood supply.
Arap and colleagues have turned this approach against fat.
It makes sense, Arap argues -- fat cells grow and proliferate quickly just as cancer cells do. Like tumors, they build themselves a scaffold of tiny blood vessels called capillaries for sustenance.
Cancer drugs tackle different proteins involved in building blood vessels. Arap's team looked for a protein that might be found only in the blood vessels that feed fat cells.
They found one. Prohibitin is active on the surface of fat-feeding blood vessels. They also found a monoclonal antibody -- a synthetic immune system molecule -- that finds and attaches to prohibitin alone.
...they put normal mice on what they called a "cafeteria diet." "It is high in calories," Arap said in a telephone interview. The mice started out weighing just under an ounce, 20 to 25 grams, but more than doubled their weight on the diet.
Then they injected half the mice with the new fat-killing molecule. After daily injections for a month, the fat mice lost, on average, 30 percent of their body weight.
"The weight loss was also accompanied by a reversal of fatty liver and glucose intolerance," Arap said, describing two common complications of obesity. "They actually looked better."
Well, almost everyone: after the silly BMI (Marilyn Monroe was seriously underweight? Michael Jordan was teetering between obesity and morbid obesity?) was adopted it was decided it was not scary enough, so it was "adjusted" and roughly 20 million US citizens went from "normal" to "obese" without gaining an ounce...
Now, I consider myself fat-to-obese. And I keep reading medical weblogs, occasionally seeing posts about it. And my own "primary physician" is actually a medical clinic at a teaching hospital, so when the interns/residents turn over each year I get the start of the weight lecture.
Why just "the start" of the lecture? Because I interrupt and tell them -
^ A few years ago I was hospitalized for two weeks. During
^ that time I ate the same hospital food as everyone else,
^ and of course the same portions. I got the same amount of
^ exercise - a bit more than I normally do.
^
^ I gained twelve pounds in those two weeks.
^
^ If you aren't prepared to offer a believable reason for
^ that, I cannot accept anything you say except that cutting
^ down to 1200 calories per day and walking five miles per
^ day would cause a weight loss. It would also kill me, but
^ does that bother you?
I've never had anyone attempt the lecture a second time.
Changing diet and exercise will help most (well, those who can stand it) people. Note, though, it has to be a permanent change: lose-gain-lose-gain cycling is FAR more unhealthy than being overweight, up to the "morbidly" obese point.
Once you have a certain percentage of fat, it is like a cancer, if somewhat easier to treat. Indeed, one study found that some cancer-indicators in the blood also applied to fat buildup, and some cancer treatments (the ones that attack the cancer by recognizing the blood change and cutting off flow to capillaries with large concentrations of the changed blood chemistry) were effective in controlling weight: not conclusive as yet, a lot of research needs to be done, but if borne out offers hope. -
http://www.reuters.com/newsArticle.jhtml;jsessionid=KIBCCNTVLXBUMCRBAE0CFEY?type=scienceNews&storyID=5082664
Study: Molecule 'Vacuums Up' Fat from Mice
A new approach being used to fight cancer may also help fight fat, U.S. researchers said on Sunday. ... When fat mice were injected with the new "fat-zapper" every day for a month, they all slimmed down to normal weight with no visible side-effects, the researchers reported in the June [2004] issue of Nature Medicine. ... In cancer, a new class of drugs called angiogenesis inhibitors starve tumors by cutting off their blood supply.
Arap and colleagues have turned this approach against fat.
It makes sense, Arap argues -- fat cells grow and proliferate quickly just as cancer cells do. Like tumors, they build themselves a scaffold of tiny blood vessels called capillaries for sustenance.
Cancer drugs tackle different proteins involved in building blood vessels. Arap's team looked for a protein that might be found only in the blood vessels that feed fat cells.
They found one. Prohibitin is active on the surface of fat-feeding blood vessels. They also found a monoclonal antibody -- a synthetic immune system molecule -- that finds and attaches to prohibitin alone.
...they put normal mice on what they called a "cafeteria diet." "It is high in calories," Arap said in a telephone interview. The mice started out weighing just under an ounce, 20 to 25 grams, but more than doubled their weight on the diet.
Then they injected half the mice with the new fat-killing molecule. After daily injections for a month, the fat mice lost, on average, 30 percent of their body weight.
"The weight loss was also accompanied by a reversal of fatty liver and glucose intolerance," Arap said, describing two common complications of obesity. "They actually looked better."
The statistics on cancer including cancer esophageal are quite frightening. I liked the information in your blog that also included for cancer esophageal. One day everyone will be able to win the fight agaianst cancer but I fear that it will not be in my lifetime.
It's always nice to see another great site about green tea weight loss so natrually I want to tell you about my site on green tea weight loss
Thank you for the information. I have found another site at star jones weight loss.
You may find it usful as well.
You may find it usful as well.
I just came across your blog about best diet pill and wanted to drop you a note telling you how impressed I was with the information you have posted here. I also have a web site & blog about best diet pill
Just checking out the other blogs on free weight loss program and came across yours, not bad, just getting ideas for my free weight loss programblog. Take Care.
I have seen some really interesting comments on this blog about ephedra diet pill and I have gotten some great ideas for ephedra diet pill to place on my own blogs and websites about ephedra diet pill. Thanks.
I have heard about this diet where you lose 9 lbs every 11 days and helps with hoodia weight loss. Does any one have any experience with hoodia weight loss?
Wow that´s a great blog that you have there, mine is slightly differnent but it basically covers the same topics.
I have a type of cancer site. It pretty much covers Cancer related stuff.
Check it out, you won´t regret it... Cheers.. Roger From Http://www.havecancer.com
I have a type of cancer site. It pretty much covers Cancer related stuff.
Check it out, you won´t regret it... Cheers.. Roger From Http://www.havecancer.com
Want to learn more about diet dieting? I have a site related to diet dieting.
diet dieting
diet dieting
diet dieting
diet dieting
Hi. I was searching for the latest information on loss story weight and somehow, which I don't understand, found your site. I'm sure glad I found it. It's really amazing how you can sit down and look for one thing on the Internet and find totally unrelated interesting stuff. Sometimes I'll spend hours reading about stuff other than what I've been searching for. The search is on again but I just had to comment on how much I enjoyed reading the comments here.
Luck to you
RT at loss story weight
Luck to you
RT at loss story weight
I had been out looking for some new
information on Obese when I found your site.
Though not just what I was searching for, it drew
my attention. An interesting post and I thank you for it.
information on Obese when I found your site.
Though not just what I was searching for, it drew
my attention. An interesting post and I thank you for it.
Great blog. In case you care to know, I was searching for atkins written diet plan and your blog came up. I am glad I found it though.
Very nice.
Very nice.
This is a very nice site. I was out looking for "low carb diet better skin" and found your blog in the process.
Best of luck.
Best of luck.
Looking for info on Hyper-Thyroid and weight loss and Alvidar came across your blog, you might find mine of interest ##keyword ##http://www.1shoppingcart.com/app/aftrack.asp?afid=253458&u=alvidar.com lose weight,
From what I can see, not many blogs talk about stuff like dratkins low carb diet and that is sad. I think your blog is great that way.
keep it up.
keep it up.
Bloggin for info on Hyper-Thyroid and weight loss and Alvidar came across your blog, you might find mine of interest ##keyword ##http://www.1shoppingcart.com/app/aftrack.asp?afid=253458&u=alvidar.com weight loss,
Great blog. In case you care to know, I was searching for high protein granola bars recipes and your blog came up. I am glad I found it though.
Very nice.
Very nice.
From what I can see, not many blogs talk about stuff like a trip to yesteryear donna atkins and that is sad. I think your blog is great that way.
keep it up.
keep it up.
I came accross the term "lactose free high protein drinks or supplements" the other day and I did not know what it was. When I search for it I found your site. Thought you might find that interesting :)
From what I can see, not many blogs talk about stuff like high protein low fat micturition and that is sad. I think your blog is great that way.
keep it up.
keep it up.
Finding these pages was a God's blessing for me. Keep up tha quality of the posts!
burn diet pill smart
burn diet pill smart
At last a place wher I found some decent diet and weight loss articles. Congratulations.
star cap diet pill
star cap diet pill
Just a word to say that I really like your site and that I surely will return.
Sincerely,
diet weight control
Sincerely,
diet weight control
Landed here searching for diet information and think this is the place to be for valuable articles on the subject.
Best Regards,
atkins low carb diet
Best Regards,
atkins low carb diet
So many things in society today try to urge us to focus on the "self",with this "it's all about me" attitude, as couples, or companionsships, perhaps we should concentrate some of that "me" energy on "us".
Link to this site: relationship advice
http://relationship-faq.info/
Link to this site: relationship advice
http://relationship-faq.info/
Hello,
You have created a site that has beaten the competition by a long way. I have added you to my bookmarks and I will be back on a regular basis to see if you have posted any further details on this issue.
Regards,
prime
You have created a site that has beaten the competition by a long way. I have added you to my bookmarks and I will be back on a regular basis to see if you have posted any further details on this issue.
Regards,
prime
I have been blogging around for some time today when I came across your site. I just wanted to let you know that I think it is a great looking site and keep up the good work.
Regards
Treatments For Lung Cancer
Regards
Treatments For Lung Cancer
Lose Weight Now. Fasting, when done peoperly, can be a basoc part of a solid weight loss plan. If done correctly it can ne a great start to your new way of life.
Link to this site. weight loss vitamin supplement
http://better-weightloss.info
Link to this site. weight loss vitamin supplement
http://better-weightloss.info
Hi there:)
I am new here and I just want to say what a great you have. I have had the pleasure of visiting. I hope to find loads of useful snippets of information here from now on!
Regards,
make work home money at
I am new here and I just want to say what a great you have. I have had the pleasure of visiting. I hope to find loads of useful snippets of information here from now on!
Regards,
make work home money at
well hello there
I just visited your blog about plastic surgery phoenix and I like what I see..why not get on over to my site at http://www.medicare-cosmetic-surgery.com and take a look at what I have to say about plastic surgery phoenix
I just visited your blog about plastic surgery phoenix and I like what I see..why not get on over to my site at http://www.medicare-cosmetic-surgery.com and take a look at what I have to say about plastic surgery phoenix
Oh well not everyone needs to agree. But I do!.Need to finish my report on how to help someone quit smoking.Thank you very much,how to help someone quit smoking.
weight loss diet Weight Loss Tips - 101 Weight Loss Plan
101 Plan to Lose 10 Pounds or more and Keep it Off!
There was a time in this world when the need to lose weight was completely unheard of. People ate well, but the worked well too. They woke up early in the morning and then engaged in a whole day's work.
The world has changed so much since those days. Life styles have changed and the comforts and facilities have increased so much. But every rose has its thorn. Weight Loss Tips weight loss diet