<$BlogRSDUrl$>

Wednesday, December 15, 2004

Philip Carter Gets It 
In an op-ed piece in the New York Times, Phil Carter correctly percieves that the whole flap about armored trucks is not a failure of the Rumsfeld Pentagon so much as a failure of several decades of Army doctrine writers at Ft. Leavenworth, Fort Sill, Fort Knox, and Fort Benning to forsee the nonlinear battlefield.

Actually, the problem runs much deeper than the current administration: it stems from the Pentagon's uneven effort over the last decade to turn a cold-war military into a force able to meet today's challenges.

For 40 years, Army doctrine centered on what's known as a linear battlefield. Combat units line up shoulder to shoulder across a broad front to face the enemy, which organizes its units in much the same fashion. Support units operate in relative safety in the rear, with only the occasional enemy infiltration to worry about.

Under this model, trucks in logistical units can afford to do without armor, and their drivers can make do with just an M-16 rifle; there's no need for Kevlar door panels or .50-caliber machine guns because the enemy is taken care of by combat units at the front. This was the way the Army won World War II.


Exactly correct, except that the failure is even worse.

World War II was NOT a particularly linear conflict.

Indeed, Heinz Guderian, the architect of the blitzkrieg doctrine in the German Army, pretty much did away with the linear battlefield. Where defenses were linear, they were almost uniformly failures on the World War II battlefield.

The Americans quickly adopted much of the blitzkrieg doctrine, and eventually improved upon it in France in 1944, under the command of Generals George Patton and Omar Bradley - a vastly underrated figure with the American public.

German troops played havoc with American rear areas during the Battle of the Bulge. And George Patton terrorized German rear areas right back throughout the rest of the fight, by moving faster than the Germans could battle track, and consistently operating inside the German decision cycle.

Erwin Rommel wrote in his memoirs: "in desert warfare, there is no front line. Or more accurately, it is front all around."

German rail lines were consistent targets of sabotage, especially on the Eastern Front (The French resistance, for all their obnoxious bragging and hopeless romanticization in movies like "Top Secret" was never very large, nor very effective. Most of their best members died in Nazi (and French!) torture chambers, anyway)

General Stillwell managed to go nonlinear in South East Asia. Mao Tse Tung revolutionized warfare by fighting nonlinear, guerrilla actions against the Japanese, who also had trouble securing outlying areas in the Phillipines.

Indeed, conceptually, the whole South and Central Pacific campaigns were exercizes in nonlinear warfare.

Soft areas--logistics support areas, command and control nodes--have been targets of warfare from the dawn of time. U.S. AirLand Battle doctrine and the USMCs "How To Fight" manual of maneuver warfare (I can't remember what it's called now, exactly, except that it was excellent reading for me as a platoon leader) both insisted on it, and held forth the concept that it was acme not to target the enemy's combat formations with your own--this is a failure of strategy--but to maneuvre around them and strike at the enemy's rear areas, and force them to withdraw or come to you.

But when you do that, guess who's between you and your own rear areas?

That's right: the enemy.

I remember standing in the motor pool one morning with a bunch of soldiers in Fort Stewart, GA, right before we deployed. We were initiating a round of PMCS on the vehicles, and I wanted to emphasize how important our maintenance effort was.

So I gathered people around and told them "let me tell you how the next battle's going to go."

I then predicted that our time in Jordan would be limited, and we would be called into Iraq. We would enter Iraq in a long, hellacious convoy along an MSR. A vehicle would break down, attracting crowds of curious Iraqis. One of them would have a cell phone, and call his buddies. In 20 minutes, we would be attacked.

The bottom line: DON'T be the guy who's vehicle breaks down! Do your PMCS, and do it right!

Most of that came to pass, except that we got lucky--when a vehicle broke down, it was usually out in the middle of nowhere. I've been wrong about a lot of things. But I was right about the Jordan mission becoming obsolete as soon as Baghdad fell, and I was right about the convoy from Hell getting into Iraq, I was right about the asshat with the cell phone, and I was right about the 20 minutes.

And I was right in suspecting that we would face an intifada style insurgency, and that it would largely target CSS assets. They'd be stupid not to.

So the failure of doctrine writers to anticipate that our convoys would be prime targets: that the battle would be nonlinear EVEN as we sought nonlinear battlefields, is a great failure indeed.

Now, what will be the nature of the NEXT war?

Splash, out

Jason





Comments:
America has a bit of war history like what is happening in Iraq. The Kansas/Missouri conflict was major, starting years before the American Civil War and lasting till it was over. It bred folk heroes like Jesse James for the same reasons Osama B.L. is still not caught. There might be something to learn by a study of this period. It would require honest history, and that has been hard to find until recent years. It took a little over a hundred years for historians to present an unbiased look at the cause & effects.

General Orders evicted the entire population from counties in Missouri. It was the only way to control the area. The area became a no man's land.

The insurgents (Missouri Bushwhackers) gave up when the war ended. They were young men who knew nothing but killing and dieing but only a few became outlaws.
 
Ha! It's great that 'Top Secret' is THE definitive documentary on French military prowess.
 
I just came across this blog and saw a post aboutfrench bulldog rescue. This reminded me that I learned french recently with this:french bulldog rescue Maybe it can help someone else.
 
INTERESTING BLOG ON free ringtone for a nokia cell phone REALLY ENJOYED IT. I HAVE A RELATED SITE HERE free ringtone for a nokia cell phone
 
Hey great site, good reading and will be back for more, thanks..
Check out some of these sites to download stuff to your cell / mobile phone.. Cheers Phil
ringtones
ringtones
ringtones
ringtones
ringtones

Thanks again...
 
**eLearning**
 
Wow! Awesome blog... Check me out if you get a chance :camera cell free phone
 
Sometimes, these gambles pay off, but there are occasions when they fail miserably,
 
Mobile phone content like ringtones are very popular. Other mobile software applications could become more popular as phones develop. As ringtones , Java Games etc. become more available to all the countries, and in more languages like Chinese, the market for mobile content will grow even more.
 
Hey, you have a great blog here! I'm definitely going to bookmark you!

I have a car truck part site/blog. It pretty much covers ##KEYWORD## related stuff.

Come and check it out when you have the time :-)
 
Hey there Blogger, I was looking for info. Blog on sprint ringtones and I found your blog-site. this post isn’t exactly what I was searching for but it did get my and interest. Now I know why I found your excellent blog-site when I was looking for sprint ringtones related information and I’m glad I did even though its not an exact find. Great Informative Post, thanks for the.
 
Blogger, today I was looking for a nice blog experience on cell free phone ringer and I found your website. this post wasn’t exactly what I was looking for but it did get my attention and interest. I see why I arrived on your excellent website when I was searching for cell free phone ringer related information and I’m glad I did even though its not an exact fit.
 
if u want an ipod, you can go to www.getipodsforfree.com and do an offer. follow the instructions and they'll actually send you a freeipod, no joke, there's reviews all over the internet
 
I’m out searching the web for the latest
and greatest information on ringtone and found your
great site. Although this post wasn’t specifically
what I was looking for it definitely got my interest
and attention. I see now why I found your interesting
blog when I was looking for ringtone related
information and I’m grateful I found your site even
though its not a perfect match. Great Post, thanks
for your informative site,
 
Hi there Blogger, nice site looks like you did your
homework. I would love if you check out my ringtone site.
Thanks for the info. ringtone
 
Hi Blogger, I’m out searching the web for the latest
and greatest information on free sprint ringtone and found your
great site. Although this post wasn’t specifically
what I was looking for it definitely got my interest
and attention. I see now why I found your interesting
blog when I was looking for free sprint ringtone related
information and I’m grateful I found your site even
though its not a perfect match. Great Post, thanks
for your informative site,
 
I just came across your blog about crazy frog ringtone and wanted to drop you a note telling you how impressed I was with the information you have posted here. I also have a web site & blog about crazy frog ringtone so I know I'm talking about when I say your site is top-notch! Keep up the great work, you are providing a great resource on the Internet here! You can checkout my site at crazy frog ringtone
 
Christmas is just around the corner. No time to go to the mall...then do your shopping online. We sell everything that the mall sells. Shop today!
 
Shebang!
data pilot serial number
 
Nice Blog!
irda software
 
Thanks very much for your blog. You have such a candid way of sharing your ideas with others. The crazy dog toy information that you have here has helped me tremdously!
 
Ever wonder about why we all have so much to say. I just had to post. See, even I'm doing it. Great content. Well done!
free ringtones
 
Ever wish you could surf all day. I wish I could. I can only say you ahve a great blog and take off. Want to find a free kyocera ringtone site sometime today. Again, thanks.
 
Hello Bloggers,

My name is Chris. As your blog is consumer electronics product related, i would like to invite you to my new site : http://www.newelectronicsproducts.com
It is free, it is updated daily and you can use rss feed to get the lastest info on electronics products.
Thanks for your time and thanks for letting me use your blog
Chris
 
Hi Guys,

consumer guide electronics : i get my lastest electronics news on consumer guide electronics
Daily updated site with rss feed.
Anyone knows a better one ?
Thanks

Gregy
 
IS YOUR DOG FAT:
Obesity is one of the greatest health concerns facing dogs, you can and should do something about it right now.
Link to this site: pet health supply
http://pet-faq.info/
 
How's' it going? During my search for supply computer desks information I came across your blog.

I found it interesting, too bad I gotta look elsewhere for supply computer desks info...but I'm going to bookmark your cool blog anyway.
 
Nice blog! I was looking for topics on student cheap calls, but came across your blog along the way.

I'm going to have to bookmark you so that I can come back and read more later. For now I'm going to continue looking for student cheap calls topics for my site.
 
What I like about the cyberworld I live in 18 hours a day is the random nature of the landscape. Here I am on your site, posting. Yet you might live a 1000 miles away. Then, I could search for ringtone graphic, and be 1000 miles away from that blog (you know, meaning where the person who blogs lives). Sorry to rant. Good blogging.
 
Hi, great blog! Keep it up.

I have a web site. It pretty much covers new movie download related stuff.
Come and have a look if you get time :-)
Over 15 billion files - Instant access to the largest network on the planet! Watch what you want when you want it.
250 times faster than any other site!
new movie download
 
How's' it going Blogger? During my search for internet service providers (isps) information I came across your blog.

I found it interesting, too bad I gotta look elsewhere for internet service providers (isps) info...but I'm going to bookmark your cool blog anyway.
 
Hello,

I (student) am posting to tell you that your blog is most impressive!! I would like to become a member..

Regards,
Remove Adware
 
Hi,

My sister wanted to congratulate you on such a blog you have.

She doesn't know how to type well,
and might waste an hour to create one post:)

We both give you our best of luck, and hope that this blog remains our favourite.

Thanks (Elaine),
make money fast
 
Hello,

I am willing to re-read your blog more than once, cause it is very interetsting! Thanks.

Regards,
start online business
 
Nice blog! Hey Blogger, I was looking for topics on office furniture , but came across your blog along the way.

I'm going to have to bookmark you so that I can come back and read more later. For now I'm going to continue looking for office furniture topics. Have a good one.:-)
 
Hey cool best traffic generation system blog! I just wanted everyone to know about this new traffic generation system. It's the BOMB! Invented my an Italian schoolteacher and unconditionally guaranteed to work. Now, everyone struggling with best traffic generation system and no matter how small your website or affiliate website is, can compete with the big boys! This is like nothing you've ever seen or heard of before and it gets you unlimited targeted traffic daily to your best traffic generation system blog or website. I thought I'd level the playing field for a change. Us underdogs in Internet Marketing who are trying hard to make a living online and who are really struggling at it, this is our new secret weapon! Please unite bloggers and small webmasters and get this best traffic generation system . Big Dogs Take Heed....We are Coming! Thanks for your time and spread the word about this new system. We CAN succeed just like the big boys. Oh, did I tell you, you can get #1 search engine listings for your keywords and you won't get banned like the other 'lame' systems out there will? By the way, dude. Far Out, Blog, man.
For free web traffic secrets- go to: http://www.Free-Traffic-Guru.com and it is much appreciated. ;-)
 
Hey there,
I was just cruising the blogs today and I came across yours, it really entertained me.

Thanks,

dog health holistic
 
Hi there Blogger, nice site looks like you did your
homework. I would love if you check out my free sprint ringtone site.
Thanks for the info. free sprint ringtone
 
dildos dildos
double dong double dong
eggs bullets eggs bullets
enhancement products enhancement products
enlarging pumps enlarging pumps
female stimulators female stimulators
fetish fantasy fetish fantasy
adult toys adult toys
 
Post a Comment

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?

Site Meter

Prev | List | Random | Next
Powered by RingSurf!

Prev | List | Random | Next
Powered by RingSurf!