<$BlogRSDUrl$>

Tuesday, November 16, 2004

Why the low casualties? 
Another reader emails:

[Casualties in Fallujah have been]Remarkably low for a week of
urban fighting. Any idea what is going on?

Low numbers of enemy?
All the urban combat training paying off?
Massive firepower?
Corpsmen in the right place at the right time?

What do you think?



It's a variety of things, although "low" casualties is always a relative term. Casualties can be above or below your expectations, and above or below what you planned for. But if it's you bleeding out...or worse yet, one of your troops...then casualties will seem unbearably high.

Nevertheless, military doctrine does provide some guidance regarding casualty expectations. As an assistant Brigade 4 (very briefly) and a Bn S-1 (twice), when I was doing planning and manpower projections, I used an operating assumption of 25% casualties in the offense, and 10% in the defense for a given battle, plus an assumption that on any given day, infantry in the field would suffer 2% casualties from illness, sprained ankles, car wrecks, heat exhaustion, etc. You HAVE to do these progressions, because you have to anticipate your casualty figures BEFORE the battle, in order to order your replacement troops (by rank and military occupational specialty.

The 2% a day figure was usually pretty good. Fortunately, the 25% casualty estimate was far too high in Iraq (although far too low at the National Training Center.

Given the amount of time the insurgent had to prepare the Fallujah battlefield, casualties are about what I thought they might be in Fallujah. Perhaps a little higher...it's tough for me to get a sense of how big the fight is. I.e., are the battalions in the fight reinforced with additional companies?

But then again, this is no Stalingrad for US forces. Casualties are very low by historical standards. There are several reasons for this.

1.) Most importantly, the Iraqi insurgent is a terrible marksman. The AK 47 is a fine assault rifle, but often the insurgent will use a sawed off stock and engage using the 'spray and pray' method. The Marines, in contrast, are excellent marksmen. And as a result, any given engagement will turn one-sided very quickly.

2.) Air power is being used in lieu of close assault. In WWII, Korea, and Viet Nam, it was almost unheard of to devote a 500 lb. bomb on a building occupied by a measly two squads of irregulars. Now it's a matter of course. As it should be. Bombs are cheaper than Marines and soldiers. I believe in reconnaisance by fire, the forgiveness of sins, and the chemlight everlasting.

3.) Body armor. We have body armor, they don't. Which means that a good number of marines and sailors who would have been wounded or killed in past wars now just have collectors' item ceramic plates. And in an engagement, our guys who might have been wounded in past wars keep putting rounds down range. Which contributes to fire superioriority.

4.) Good troop quality. In Viet Nam, urban warfare was the exception. In Iraq, urban warfare is the norm. The platoons have competent infantry who've been around the block a few times, and TTPs for urban operations have already been well developed.

5.) Overwhelming firepower.

6.) Better communications than we've ever had,coupled with GPS and satellite imagery, and troops down to the squ allowing better articulation of forces, and quicker maneuver to the decisive point. If the insurgents take a stand anywhere, they will quickly find themselves pinned down by Yankee .50 cal fire, and an element from out of nowhere appearing in their flanks and rear. So he must withdraw. But when he withdraws, he exposes himself to be hit again.

That's how things went down in Najaf. That's how things are going down in Fallujah.


Splash, out

Jason



Remarkably low for a week of
urban fighting. Any idea what is going on?

Low numbers of enemy?
All the urban combat training paying off?
Massive firepower?
Corpsmen in the right place at the right time?

What do you think?

Comments:
G'day Blogger, what a great blog you have here, been entertained by the read. Just noticed that my intended brief time visiting blogs looking for currency trading platform items has run into a couple of hours. Easily done when you get engrossed in what people write about. I should really use currency trading platform as a search term but then I might miss places such as this post. Besides which working all the time is boring.
 
Hi there. Kinda busy, but looking for information on trading. Nice blog, good info. Maybe visit my site if you're looking for trading related material trading. Thanks
 
Hi there. Kinda busy, but looking for information on stocks. Nice blog, good info. Maybe visit my site if you're looking for stocks related material stocks. Thanks
 
Hi there. Kinda busy, but looking for information on forex trade. Nice blog, good info. Maybe visit my site if you're looking for forex trade related material forex trade. Thanks
 
Hi there. Kinda busy, but looking for information on forex book. Nice blog, good info. Maybe visit my site if you're looking for forex book related material forex book. Thanks
 
I have been following a site now for almost 2 years and I have found it to be both
reliable and profitable. They post daily and their stock trades have been beating
the indexes easily.

Take a look at Wallstreetwinnersonline.com

RickJ
 
I have been following a site now for almost 2 years and I have found it to be both
reliable and profitable. They post daily and their stock trades have been beating
the indexes easily.

Take a look at Wallstreetwinnersonline.com

RickJ
 
Hi. Your issues are so important and your post is aimed at all Americans and the world community. I just wanted to thank you. Maybe future trading simulator, isn't exactly related to your blog but I think reading your blog may just help. Keep up the great articles and blogs.

See you later
RT at future trading simulator,
stumbling across your blog. VERY GOOD! It's a welcome break. If you don't mind I'd like to add your blog to my favorites list so I can come back later on and read some more stuff. Keep blogging away!

Bye and see you later
RT at future trading simulator,
 
Shop at your favorite stores 24 hours a day. Why go to the mall when you can shop online and avoid the traffic
 
I started posting some pictures I had taken in 1968 while in Vietnam and added some captions. I'm not selling anything and came to your site for some ideas. Nice job and unique to say the least. Take a look if you get a chance. ---Jack--- vietnam war pictures
 
Hi, I am doing a study on used cars and hope you don't mind my small comment on your Blog
 
Just blogging for a while, my site is also about egold, so just saying what's up.

Charles
 
One crazy blog you have here. love it like that. LOL! Terrel - australia wholesale jewelry
 
Hi Blogger:)

We can see we share same interest.. We know it is imp that the web blog has valuable info not only words, and U have accomplished that very well.. We like it so much..

Regards,
work home make money at
 
Hello there, I find reading blog articles like yours most rewarding. It enhances the experiences of life in many cases.

Being a webmaster I tend to sometimes have a soft spot for blogs related to article database and /or sites that are built around article database type items.

Once again, thank you ##NAME##, Take care now.
 
Where do you get your ideas from. I know several other viewers that would really find this interesting. It would be great if you went by my weblog and told me if it does the job. smoking cessation advice
 
I am going to tell my family about this personal blog. This is an excellent site, is it all your own doing. Maybe you will want to take a look at my personal blog and give me an idea how to improve it. stop smoking soon
 
Your blog rocks because it's interesting in a off-beat kind of way. I was searching for topics on home business and I ended up on your blog. I'm usually more interested in Forex Signals Buy Sell. You've nailed it. With regrards to your post I think you gave some good advice and make some excellent points. From any perspective it's reasonable because it is similar to the way I write and because it seems to make for readable posts. Nice job!
 
With regrards to your post I realize that my methods aren't yet up to scratch. You're right on with your comments. Your blog rocks because I was kind of thinking along the same lines but of course, in a different context. It all fits together because there is seldom a single solution in our business. I was searching for topics on top network marketing companies and while searching Blogspot I came across your post on your blog. I try to keep to Forex Signals Buy Sell but that's not always possible. Nice job!
 
It all fits together because this is how we work in real life too. You're right on in your last post. With respect to your post I realize that my methods aren't yet up to scratch. I was searching for topics on making money and I landed on your blog. I'm usually trying to focus on Forex Signals Buy Sell but your post on your blog caught my eye. Your blog is really cool because it's a great way to learn more about trading. Nice work!
 
I had been googling for stuff on money making, but I ran into your blog. More often than not, I'm trying to learn about Foreign Currency Trading. I really liked your blog because it's a great way to learn more about trading. With respect to your post I realize I've got a few things to learn yet. It is reasonable because there is seldom a single solution in our business. You're right on with your post. Thanks for taking the time to write a great post!
 
Post a Comment

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?

Site Meter

Prev | List | Random | Next
Powered by RingSurf!

Prev | List | Random | Next
Powered by RingSurf!