<$BlogRSDUrl$>

Wednesday, October 20, 2004

Phil Carter on Reservists 
The normally well-balanced Phil Carter has taken yet another opportunity to slime reservists, this time in his article on Slate.

The professional active-duty force of today still represents the best argument for why we do not want to resume the draft:A conscript-based force simply can't achieve the skill, unit cohesion, or professionalism of today's active military.

But America's weekend warriors are a different story.

The reservists closely resemble the draftees of days gone by.


Well, our draftees have historically served this nation very well, Phil, so thanks for the complement.

Reservists train for one weekend a month and two weeks in the summer
:

Must be nice. I've got 12 years in, though, and I've never been in a unit like that.

Thirty-nine days a year is hardly enough to build true tactical competence on the complex tasks of warfighting.


That's a matter of how you use your time. You can't build proficiency in battalion level operations in the reserve components. So smart units don't even try. With good training management, though, you can build excellent units from the crew and squad level up to platoon level. Reserve component units get a leg up, actually, because their crews are together for so long. And in some MOSs, our reservists have even more experience than our active duty soldiers.

Look, a 30 year old reservist who's been driving military trucks for twelve years --and who very likely possesses a CDL as a professional full time driver at home, is simply a better and safer truck driver than a 20 year old active duty soldier who's been driving trucks for 18 months. Particularly when it comes time to haul a trailer.

The same applies to mortar and artillery crews. If I got woken up in the middle of the night by a mortar attack, I used to look at my watch and time how long it was before we launched some counterbattery fire.

The National Guard guys routinely bested the active duty guys. I mean, without fail. It's not entirely an apples to apples comparison, since the Guard guys were mortarmen and the active duty guys were artillery crews, and mortars are usually more responsive than artillery for command and control reasons.

Then again, it was an active duty FDC that launched five 155 rounds into a residential area in Ramadi one night last February because they mixed up a couple of grid coordinates. (Miraculously, no one was killed, and we replaced the homes that were destroyed and livestock lost).

Now, where the National Guard units can't compete is when we get into Brigade level operations and up, simply because there are not enough opportunities to fully train battle staffs.

But a National Guard or Reserve transportation unit, after nearly a year on active duty, is going to be fully capable of putting a platoon on the road. If properly supported.



Soldiers in logistics units like the 343rd learn how to drive their big rigs and maintain them, but they hardly have time to practice convoy defense or route reconnaissance.


Well, this unit has been DOING convoy defense for nine months. Lack of competence is not at issue here, and no one save Carter is alleging it, at least as far as these troops are concerned.

The lack of training time is compounded by other resource problems in the reserves.

Many reserve leaders don't have significant active-duty experience
,

Most of us do. Especially now. But even as an infantry platoon leader in the early 1990s, my platoon sergeant and two of my three squad leaders had CIBs. My first two platoon sergeants were veterans of Viet Nam.

Now, consider the lieutenant level. In a typical Guard unit, most lieutenants will have come from OCS or ROTC, and most were enlisted before. Some extensively. When I deployed to Iraq as a lieutenant, I was 34 years old, and had already had two commands and a JROTC rotation. All of our platoon leaders were in their late 20s or early 30s, and had already made their new lieutenant mistakes.

When you compare us to the more typical 23-24 year old lieutenants on active duty, I would argue that in many cases, the
active duty
leaders don't have significant active duty experience.

they lack the expertise necessary to train their units on these important missions. Reserve equipment—particularly in the National Guard—suffers from decades of neglect.


True. But that has nothing to do with the reservists in question. The resource allocation and procurement decisions are made in Washington. By people on active duty.


Further, this unit has been in Iraq for more than 9 months already. For all intents and purposes, they are quite literally active duty soldiers.

When the Army created its "total force concept"—the mix of active and reserve forces it has today—after the Vietnam War, it allocated combat units mostly to the active force, while support and logistics units were put in the reserves. The Army assumed it didn't need highly trained truck drivers on active duty as badly as it needed infantrymen, tankers, and aviators on active duty.


False. Since about 1967, the combat arms formations have been roughly equally split between the active and reserve components, thanks to the Abrams doctrine with almost all the combat arms units going to the National Guard (with the exception of the 100th/442nd, which is a Reserve unit in Hawaii and Samoa)

Reservists today get mobilized, trained on the most basic tasks of war, and then shipped to Iraq in a matter of weeks.


No, that's not true by a long shot. Reservists don't just materialize out of thin air right before mobilization. It takes some time to ramp fully up to speed, but you aren't starting with basic trainees.

The reservists in Iraq lack the training, equipment, leadership, and resources to do their job.


Hogwash. This platoon has been doing its job for nine months. Our reservists and guardsmen have been doing their JOBS since September 11th! Many in shortage MOSs are on their second tours. A few are on their third, counting homeland defense and safe skies duty.

Most reserve units I had the honor to work with overseas performed terrifically. By August 2003, you couldn't tell them apart. Both forces had become lean, mean, competent, and battle-hardened. The only difference was our troops had only two sets of clothing and the active duty guys had four. Oh, and our guys weren't getting paid.

But that wasn't the reservists' fault, either. The people responsible for paying reservists attached to active duty units were...you guessed it...active duty.

And their morale proves it; surveys conducted under the Army's auspices last year showed a marked difference between the attitudes of active-duty soldiers and Marines, and of reservists like those in the 343rd.


Gee...96% of reserve component soldiers have serious pay problems. And you wonder why they might have morale problems? The pay problems alone would explain the morale differential.

Consequently, reservists today are acting in ways that look startlingly like conscripts of yesterday.


Let's see...Carter looks at the actions of a single platoon -- on which the jury is still out -- and slimes 80,000 troops with it.

I think if Mr. Carter had seen what I've seen, and had actually integrated reserve troops into active formations in Iraq, and seen how they behave in the field, he wouldn't say that.

Splash, out

Jason




Comments:
Hi... Looks like this paid to drive thing is really taking off on the net...How about paid to drive in UK. I came accross this website that speciallizes in only paid to drive programs in the UK.. Go to ad car drive get paidand check it out. Spread the word and get paid 300 pounds a week or more for driving your own car or get given a car---WOW!!!. Thats the best.
 
Consider the power of being able to create incoming links to your site any time you want them...
 
Imagine the power of tens of thousands of other web sites being able to easily
 
I discuss this topic daily myself. I also have a website that talks about fast free make money related things. Go check it out if you get a chance.
 
Hey, you have a great blog here! I'm definitely going to bookmark you!

I have a chevy truck accessory site/blog. It pretty much covers ##KEYWORD## related stuff.

Come and check it out when you have the time :-)
 
A
 
Hi,
I came past your site while I was searching through Blogger, it is not really the information I was after about Make Money Online but I did stay to read your blog and found it interesting and well done, I do like what you have done with your site. Keep up the good work and hopefully I will visit again sometime and also find the information on Make Money Online that I was looking for in my travels.
Regards,
 
##NAME##, I spend a lot of time online checking out information on work from home and as expected I end up at a lot of sites, some that provide good information on work from home related stuff and some that don't. I recently came across your site and while #TITLE# did not provide me with the information that I was looking for, I still found it to be rather interesting, so I spent some time there checking out all the good stuff that you have there. I just want ot tell you that you should keep up the good work.
 
I enjoyed reading some of your posts Blogger. I was looking for paid survey related information and found your blog. I have a paid survey site. If you're still skeptical about taking surveys, you'll find detailed information for choosing the right paid survey for you. Great thing about surveys, they can be done part-time or full-time from home. Come and check it out if you get time :-)
If you have a site similar to mine and would like to exchange links, please contact me through my website.
 
It has been difficult for me to find real information about tonneau covers. I have search the search engines and am now looking through the blogs. However, I did enjoy your post.

--All the best,
2005 Dodge Dakota Tonneau Covers
 
how can i start a blog
 
Thanks for letting me post my used cars to your blog. I hope you get many positive comments to your blog.
 
Hi Blogger, very unique blog you have! I was looking for paid online survey related information and came across your site. Very good info, I'm definitely going to bookmark you! I have a paid online survey site. If you're still skeptical about taking surveys, you'll find detailed information for choosing the right paid survey for you. Great thing about surveys, they can be done part-time or full-time from home. Please visit it.
If you have a site similar to mine and would like to exchange links, please contact me through my website.
 
Your New 'INTERNET MALL OF THE WORLD!' small home business opportunity is over ONE-MILLION-TIMES More Powerful Than Most Affiliate Programs! Read on and discover why this is your chance to have THE MOST POWERFUL ONLINE WEALTH-BUILDING PROFIT MACHINE in history!
 
How many times have you just been out wondering about the world wide web and thought how many possible different topics there are covered. Strange things, like even Adverse credit mortgage uk, that just pops into my mind from out of nowhere and then I had to go off and find out more about it. It is so vast this huge territory of space.
Adverse credit mortgage uk
 
A fantastic blog. Keep it up. Here's a subject that may interest you; Southern California home loan http://thehomemortgageguide.com Need Information on purchasing a home? Southern California home loan
 
Blog is informative. Don't stop. Here's the secrets a lot of people are searching for; bad credit mortgage loan http://thehomemortgageguide.com New Information revealed! bad credit mortgage loan
 
Your blog is great, Here's the secrets a lot of people are searching for; California mortgage refinancing http://thehomemortgageguide.com New Information revealed! California mortgage refinancing
 
Hey what's up, just letting you know that someone from C.A. read your blog!

Regards,
Charles
home loan mortgage rate quote
 
Hey!, Just browsing around for ideas for my new. (While we're at the same topic), I'm just getting started if you want to visit:
a home mortgage calculator

Charles
 
What are these blogs all about anyway? I was surfing looking for credit card merchant when I ended up here. Back to the relentless searching for credit card merchant.
 
Just blogging for a while, found your site that also happens to be around wells fargo home mortgage payment online, so just saying what's up.

Charles
 
Hey how are you doing? just letting you know that someone from Central America read your blog!
This is my site:
new home builders, loan processors, new home mortgage
Regards,
Charles
 
Many thanks for creating your blog. It's interesting how people are different in their interests.

Thank You again,

home internet link mom.com work
 
I have been following a site now for almost 2 years and I have found it to be both reliable and profitable. They post daily and their stock trades have been beating
the indexes easily.

Take a look at Wallstreetwinnersonline.com

RickJ
 
Hello,

Thanks for setting up this blog very well - I appreciate it a lot!

Regards,
work at home make money
 
Hello,

You created this web blog using blogger.com Sure must have been a bit of work.

Please add some content to this web blog related to affiliate programs. I do not want to be rude, but you might know about some good resources.

Keep it up!
make money fast and easy
 
Found your blog again and had an interesting read. If you like come and visit mine sometime get paid to shop
 
I was searching blogsites on Google and came across yours. Very cool keep up the good work.

From http://www.surveyearn.biz/MysteryShopper/Mystery_Shopper.html my web site is about mystery shopping services
 
Hi blogger:)

I am sure you keep up this good work. Your blog was the first one to provide me with useful information...

Regards,
earn money online
 
This is a great opportunity. Just push a button 4 times per day and make $1,000's per month within one year.
 
a great opportunity, no selling, no phoning, no recruiting PERIOD!
 
First Class!
- http://www.surveyearn.biz/PaidSurveys/Work_at_home.html - legitimate work at home job
 
A military reserve force is a military organization composed of part-time military personnel, and sometimes civilians, who are available to fight when a nation mobilizes for total war or to defend against invasion. Reserve forces are generally not considered part of a permanent standing body of armed forces. The existence of reserve forces allows a nation to reduce its peacetime military expenditures while maintaining a force prepared for war. sportsbook, In some countries, such as the United States, Spain and the United Kingdom, members of the reserve forces are volunteers who have a part-time obligation. In other countries, such as the Republic of China and Israel, service in the reserves is compulsory for a number of years after one has completed their national service. Also, in some cases a militia could constitute part of a military reserve, such as the United States National Guard. A Home Guard is a specific type of reserve force that can only be activated in the event of invasion. http://www.enterbet.com
 
Post a Comment

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?

Site Meter

Prev | List | Random | Next
Powered by RingSurf!

Prev | List | Random | Next
Powered by RingSurf!